Croatia: About Cyrillic In Vukovar

Collecting signatures for referendum on Vukovar  Photo: FaH/ Damir SENCAR /ds

Collecting signatures for referendum on Vukovar
Photo: FaH/ Damir SENCAR /ds

When a group of EU parliamentarians get together to sign an open letter or statement against an issue hotly circling among the people in one of the EU member states then we start feeling uneasy about democratic freedom and political pressure and machinations evidently designed to spread certain fear or uneasiness.

The Committee for the Defence of Croatian Vukovar has collected 680,000 signatures initiating a referendum process in Croatia regarding bilingualism. The issue of Cyrillic script signage on public buildings has been at the forefront of current affairs and restlessness in Croatia for almost a year. I have written articles on this previously.
The question for the referendum is formulated as follows: “Do you agree that Article 12, clause 1, of the Constitutional Law on rights of national minorities be changed so that it reads: Equal official use of the language and script used by members of national minorities is realised in the area of local government, state government and judiciary when members of individual national minority make up at least one half of the population of that area.”
On 20th December 73 MEPs (Mainly Greens, Social Democrats and Liberals) and the European Language Equality Network (ELEN is the new European level NGO working for the promotion and protection of lesser-used languages and linguistic rights) have sent in open letters to the Croatian media voicing their concerns over the proposed referendum about Cyrillic script in Vukovar, which, if successful, would according to them undermine national minority rights, for example, raising the threshold for bilingual provision in a municipality from 33% to 50%. ELEN group say the referendum would adversely affect Serbs, Czechs, Slovaks, Italians, Hungarians, Jews, Germans, Austrians, Ukrainians, Rusins, Bosniaks, Slovenians, Montenegrins, Macedonians, Russians, Bulgarians, Polaks, Roma, Romanians, Turks, Vlachs and Albanian national minorities and contravene the Treaties that Croatia ratified in order to join the EU.
Croatian news agency HINA reports that Tomislav Josic, a leading activist in the campaign against Cyrillic signs on public institutions in the eastern Croatian town of Vukovar, has said that the issue of dual-alphabet signs is a matter for Croatia and not for the European Union.
If only our deputies were fighting for more funds from EU and for the benefit of Croatia. However, they are fighting for some other things. The Europeans are being asked to give their opinion on minorities in Croatia, while we know that in France there are no minorities at all,” Josic said.
As for 73 signatories of that letter, Josic interpreted it as only a 10% of possible signatures in the European Parliament, while the group whose leader he is collected “60%” of signatures for a petition for a referendum in Croatia on how to regulate the right of minorities to use their language and alphabet.
Josic said that it seemed to him that the activists “will be forced to collect signatures also in the European Parliament“.

Vesna Skare-Ozbolt Photo: Politikaplus.com

Vesna Skare-Ozbolt
Photo: Politikaplus.com

Vesna Skare-Ozbolt (a Lawyer with post-graduate studies in Criminal law. She served as legal advisor to the late President Franjo Tudjman for ten years. She led the process of Peaceful reintegration of Eastern Slavonia in the late 1990’s. She was Minister of Justice of the Republic of Croatia (2003-2006) and author and initiator of many legislative proposals in Croatia. She served as elected member of Croatian Parliament over three mandates from year 2000. She is also President of Democratic Centre party. Honorary citizen of Vukovar, Ilok and Brela. 1998 Woman of the Year. Decorated with the Order of Croatian Interlace, Order of Croatian Trefoil and Order of Katarina Zrinski and Vukovar Medal.  Source: http://www.vesna.com.hr)
recently wrote an article “Cyrillic and the triumph of Prime Minister Milanovic’s Will”, which was published in objektivhr.com portal and translated into English by Sonja Valcic.

After months of the status of “neither war nor peace” between the Croatian government and the Committee for the Defence of the City of Vukovar, due to the introduction of bilingualism, it has become clear that the issue cannot be solved by implementing the law ”by force.”  The citizens of Vukovar wanted that their city be granted a status of Memorial City of Victims of Serbian Aggression and as such to be exempted from the introduction of Cyrillic alphabet.

Prime Minister Zoran Milanovic had no understanding for this proposal nor did he bother to examine legal options for the realization of this proposal. Instead of listening to the politically wise President Dr. Ivo Josipovic who advocated the dialogue with the Vukovar citizens, Milanovic gave green light for setting bilingual sign plates at the crack of dawn. From that moment on, all hell broke loose: the normalization process painstakingly built for years was compromised; bilingual sign plates were flying from the Vukovar façades and from those in other cities, and the blood was shed. This was the result of placing bilingual sign plates in Vukovar which Prime Minister Milanovic called ”the triumph of the Croatian will and the state” whereas in reality that was only a triumph of his own will.

After the Croatian Parliament had refused to put the issue of Cyrillic on the agenda, the Committee had no other option but to launch an initiative for a referendum. But, since the introduction of Cyrillic alphabet in Vukovar is a complex issue, both from the legal and human perspective it is of no surprise that  the referendum question is ill-conceived: while it could not have been asked for an explicit ban on the use of the Cyrillic as this would be discriminatory, it remains unclear why the ban on the use of minority languages extends to state administration and judiciary.  Moreover, the raising of threshold for obtaining minority rights from the current 33% to 50% represents de facto a step backward in the protection of minority rights.
What is important to underline is that a deadline for the introduction of bilingual sign plates in Vukovar is an internal matter of the Republic of Croatia. The official position of the European Commission is that the issue of ”bilingual signs is within the competence of the Member States”, thus, it is utterly inappropriate for the Croatian government to „pull up the sleeve „ of the EC, begging support for the introduction of Cyrillic! The European Union does not insist on bilingualism at all costs as there are many EU member countries which have not yet resolved this issue in the best way:  i.e., Slovakia has rather restrictive laws on the use of the Hungarian minority language; Estonia also has not resolved the situation with the Russian minority, etc.
Judging by over 580,000 signatures collected for the referendum on Cyrillic across the country, the conditions for introducing Cyrillic in Vukovar are not met: the citizens of Vukovar are still waiting that war criminals who, due to the lack of evidence at the moment of the promulgation of the Amnesty Law escaped from justice, are waiting for the citizens of Serbian nationality to help them find their missing citizens which can be done in a way that would not put local Serbs at risk. It is time that the Serbs from Vukovar take an active role in building of co-existence; just asking for their rights but not wanting to reveal information about the missing and killed is not a good way towards building a good relationship with the Croats in Vukovar.
In such circumstances the only politically correct option would be to leave the representatives of both Serb national minority and those of Croatian citizens to agree when the time for introducing of Cyrillic is ripe. Until this moment, there are no legal obstacles for granting a special status to the city including the postponement of the introduction of Cyrillic by law, without bidding deadlines from both sides. There are some who say that such status would ”freeze” the development of the city, but it makes no sense: only happy people who have jobs and the youth who sees the prospect for their future make one city alive. It could be assumed that some do not like to see Vukovar being portrayed as a victim and they would prefer that all signs be eliminated suggesting Croatia was a victim of Serbian aggression.
For the time being the speculation that for the Croatian Serbs Cyrillic is important only as a step toward restoring the status of a state-building nation and for a potential autonomy in the future, needs to be put aside. The only thing which is now important is to let the people of Vukovar decide on Cyrillic themselves…
Even if the referendum does not take place – as the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia will probably be called to establish whether the issue of the referendum is constitutional or not – all the effort of the Committee for the Defence of the City of Vukovar was not in vain: a huge number of signatures in favour of referendum collected across Croatia is the message to the Government that this issue cannot be resolved from the office of the St. Mark’s Square but only through a dialogue with the representatives of both nationalities living in the City of Vukovar.
This is also a message to Milorad Pupovac, the representative of the Croatian Serb minority and the president of SDSS (Independent Democratic Serb Party) to refrain from providing inappropriate statements regarding the referendum initiative, such as ”…Milosevic did the same thing in Serbia…” as such statements aggravate not only the position of the Serbs in Vukovar but also in the entire Croatia. Moreover these signatures are also a message to all the politicians to stop their political trading across the back of the citizens of Vukovar.

__________________________
During the past couple of weeks there has been a significant number of criticisms about the formulation of the referendum question (as set out above). Many say it is not well formulated in the legal sense. Hence we are awaiting a decision from the Constitutional court in Croatia regarding the matter. There is a fair consensus among legal professionals (including the author of above article, Vesna Skare-Ozbolt) that it would have perhaps been much better had the referendum concentrated on declaring Vukovar as a special place of piety (perhaps it should have included other Croatian towns too).

One can expect that whatever the Constitutional court decide the referendum will go ahead; perhaps even a re-formulation of the question will be called for? However, it would seem to me that the desired status of a special place of piety would have formed a platform for a more positive move towards bringing closure to the still open questions of war in Croatia. This way there does not seem to be any word in association with the referendum on the still missing persons, there are no positive movements in holding the Serbs accountable for the horrors perpetrated against Croatia, there are multitudes of known or suspected Serb war criminals that have achieved amnesty for their crimes through deals made by former Croatian governments and president and this amnesty is a deep and open wound to Croats – and there are more and more accusations against Croatia regarding “the horrors” persons suffered as Serbs in Croatia in 1991!

It is to be emphasised that, regardless of media write-ups or claims to the contrary, Croats have never been against the rights of ethnic minorities and they have never even expressed anything against positive discrimination when it comes to minorities. Someone or some group with political agendas are obviously trying to turn the fight for victims’ rights in Vukovar into discrimination against minority rights!

It is to be remembered that during Croatia’s negotiations with the EU, for membership, Croatia was expected to behave in line of some political precedent towards its open enemy (Serbia). The pressure for this “task”, which no self-respecting nation would ever place upon itself and which often bore the hallmarks of humiliation, seemed to come from Britain and its political satellites in the EU (perhaps even the same players who hoodwinked Croatia into the unnatural Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes in 1918 – the Kingdom to be ruled by Serb king, who married into Queen Victoria’s family?). One could see that this pressure was never about creating rights for the Serb minority in Croatia but about creating chaos in Croatia, creating radical social situations and eventually stopping Croatia from becoming a member of the EU in order to achieve a new re-arrangement of political positions in the region. Along with this went the trumped-up charges against Croatian leadership for the so-called joint criminal enterprise during the Carla Del Ponte ICTY prosecution leadership. Aware of such positions the Croatian Serbs continued serving those interests, especially their leaders, openly positioned themselves as some kind of partners of the Republic of Croatia, without an inkling of a real intention to integrate into Croatia’s cultural, political, social and community values.

And so, the question of 50% rather than 33% of ethnic minority in a local government area of Croatia for achieving the right to bilingual usage does not seem to relate to ethnic minorities but rather to an authentic issue of national interests and the threshold of protest against humiliation.  And, indeed, Croatia simply cannot be a hostage to the real Greater Serbia and anti-Croatian politics. The 680,000 signatures for the referendum say that loud and clear! Ina Vukic, Prof. (Zgb); B.A., M.A.Ps. (Syd)

RELATES POSTS:

https://inavukic.com/2013/10/26/croatia-cyrillic-tampers-with-our-hearts-croats-announce-referendum-on-bilingual-ethnic-minority-rights/

https://inavukic.com/2013/09/03/croatia-blood-boils-in-vukovar-once-again-this-time-for-human-decency/

https://inavukic.com/2013/04/07/croatia-some-60000-rally-against-cyrillic-in-vukovar/

https://inavukic.com/2013/02/23/todays-croatian-responsibilities-no-cyrillic-in-vukovar/

Comments

  1. I would like to suggest to the Serbian minority in Vukovar, to GIVE UP their demand for Cyrillic script, as a peace offering, as an act of good will towards their citizens, an act showing they wish to live in peace and bury the ugly memories of aggression on Croatia. .

    After all, let’s not forget that in Yugoslavia, the official language was Serbo-Croatian. That is how similar the languages are. Also, I do not believe that there is a single Serb unable to read the latinic script.

    Like

  2. If only those ancients hadn’t tried to build the Tower of Babel we wouldn’t have to worry about language! It is so divisive; in Catalonia this year the dual language signs were almost all defaced. The Catalans scratch out the Spanish and the Spanish scratch out the Catalan. It must cost a fortune to keep replacing them!
    I was interested in that statement that France has no minority languages. I don’t think this is right. Although only French is approved as the official language there are a few others including Basque.
    I hope you had a good Christmas?

    Like

    • Thank you Andrew yes I have had a good Christmas Day and Boxing Day, which is also feast of St Stephen, which is a huge day too in Croatia – a lot of Stephens (Stjepan) around. As to the quote re ethnic minorities in France I am not certain what Josic meant, perhaps he was alluding to realisation or not of right of ethnic minorities when it come to bilingual signage on government buildings in various towns/areas across France? Hope you had a good Christmas too!

      Like

  3. Ina, Thank You very much, for everything.

    Like

  4. Milanovic is to blame for this situation. He forced the issue to divert attention from his failed economic and social policies and incompetent government. Serbs, also bare much blame and accountability. If they truly wanted to reconcile with Croats and be part of Croatia, they through their leaders would have demanded a delay of Cyrillic script on government buildings. But they do not want this; they want a Greater Serbia. This is all part of a bigger plan to eventually secede from Croatia through small steps that will eventually lead to autonomy and then outright independence and ultimately unification with Serbia. The plan is so simple and we Croats are unwise and unprepared for this continuation of the homeland war on a political, cultural and social front. I believe that we should act like France or the USA – one official language, one official culture, one official history, one official school system. It’s easy to do, it’s in our interest and it’s for our survival. Be who you want to be in Croatia, but Croatia should not be anything other than Croatian. One last thing, we Croatians are always on the defensive, while Serbs continually attack, they never defend – they only attack even when defending; at most their defence is about diversion then attack. It’s time Croatia learned some valuable lessons.

    Like

  5. Michael Silovic says:

    Ina , you know my position on Vukovar. Vukovar is to Croatia what the Vatican is to Rome.Vukovar is our sacred city and it should be respected at all cost.There should be one language only ( Croat ) regardless of minority status of 30% or 50 %. My solution to the problem would be to make all the Serbs disappear ( if they don’t want to accept Croatia )so they don’t reach the 30% or 50% status. You know some will say that is extreme but it is better then to have another full blown war which we all know that is what the Serbs will eventually want to have if this passes. The American government calls similar actions (even shooting) type of action preemptive strike to protect their best interest and practices this action on a daily basis and we are no different.They want nothing more then to steal Vukovar from us.Former President Clinton understands this more then some of our own government that this is nothing more then an attempt to take over Vukovar from us in a greater Serbia that they are still trying to achieve. As to the British government you know many are a bunch of scumbags who have never been a friend of Croatia throughout our history and still should never be trusted.At this time in the world where nationalism is being demanded because people are tired of minorities rights becoming more important then their own we should prevail at all cost and no one should say otherwise.Why is it those EU countries want to get rid of their minorities but we are supposed to accept them…. ~ Za Dom Spremni ~

    Like

    • A firm hand is needed Michael, that is for sure. There are many Serbs living in Vukovar who are happy to comply and do not fight for Cyrillic, respecting the victims – Croatian government should listen to them, if they need to listen to Serbs at all, and not the political garbage that poisons life and peace.

      Like

  6. La Multi Ani 2014 !

    Aliosa.

    Like

  7. If Serbs are so desperate for Cyrillic, well the border isn’t too far from Vukovar. Go build your greater Serbia elsewhere. Go pester Bulgaria, don’t you share more history with them? And for anyone who thinks I’m being derogative towards Serbs or overreacting, don’t forget that war criminals got rewarded with 1/3 of Bosnia and look at how well that’s turning out for Bosnian-Croats. Don’t be naive and think that this can’t lead to Serbian leadership trying to establish their greater Serbia goals through politics. (With Croatia’s neo-commies helping, of course). What Croatians need however, is leadership that will firmly stand up to Serbia’s tactics and that will not trample all over the people they lead. It’s time to stop just passively being on the defense every time Serbia plays the poor little victim.

    Like

    • New leadership in Croatia is needed, that’s for sure, Kat. More proactive energy and firm reactive measures are needed and the political elite in Croatia has proven it has no capacity for it

      Like

    • Michael Silovic says:

      Thank you Kat for your comments as this is what I have been saying all along and you are 100% on target as to what they are trying to accomplish. The bigger threat is the re-population of Serbs into vukovar if this passes and we wind up with a Serbian goverment in control of the city through the voting process. Our biggest mistake was going into the EU with nothing gained but a pledge to kiss Serbian azz to appease other people while we got nothing for it. I can tell you now that if this happens we will be at war again not only with the Serbs but with our own goverment as well.I can not under any circumstances see our people allow Serbia to control Vukovar with our governments help so they will both be declared an enemy of the people. We need to move very quickly and be prepared to defend our sacred city and country…..~ Za Dom Spremni ~

      Like

  8. Some 500 people are still missing in Vukovar area … to local Serbs have been given an opportunity to give anonymous tip where those people are, but very, very little tips was given, if any ….. WHY ? … During the occupation of that region, Serbs was placing a land mine fields, and they have a lay out scheme for it … after the war, they refuse to show those lay outs … WHY? … A lot of war criminals were remain in town, and local Serbs know exactly who they are, but dont want to witness …. all they want is their “rights” … serbian schools, serbian local authonomy, jobs in administration, local police department, and local documents in cyrillic alphabet … they obviously dont give a damn about Croatia and Croats … so why should we give a damn about them ? ……. A lot of money was spent to rebuild Vukovar, so all the cityzens can live in normal conditions .. occupation was last for some seven years. What was they doing there .. nothing .. they didnt rebuildt a single house, did they clean up ruins? … NO … they lived there like a dirty rats in ghoust town …We, the Croats, and our government, we rebuild the city … I am sorry for my harsh language, but all of this is just cold facts

    Like

    • Yes Vordag, there’s a great deal to sort out and I too completely disapprove of the fact that that Serb aggressor will still not reveal where the missing persons are, will still not hand over the landmine plans so that landmines could be removed instead of much money needing to be spent to find them and remove them while threat of death stays. Responsibilities come with citizens’ rights and it seems many Vukovar Serbs who are shouting for rights do not want responsibilities. You are not harsh at all, you are just being truthful. Thank you on your comment

      Like

  9. You preach hatred

    Like

  10. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KfvRR-fYv2c you wouldn’t listen to his would you?

    Like

    • Why wouldn’t I listen to this song, dinicl1? It’s title is “I remember” and lyrics that go with it go “No matter what they do to me, I remember….” Very appropriate and relevant for victims of violence and brutal attacks in particular.

      Like

  11. It’s too socialist?!?!?!

    Like

  12. Tomislav Rapin says:

    The finger of blame for this should be squarely pointed at our politicians – both those in power today and those in the past whose lack of foresight allowed for this situation to happen at all. The Serbs are only playing by the rules we ourselves have set and it’s unreasonable on our behalf to expect them to do anything other than take what is being offered to them (by our Constitution and laws).

    For those of you calling for extreme measures, keep in mind that the Domovinski rat was fought in the defence of democracy as much as it was for Croatian independence. Nothing, not even the fear of Greater Serbianism, is justification for abandoning the democratic and civil principles we fought for (and ultimately won) in the 1990’s. Straying down that path would only serve to vindicate Serbian claims before the war that any independent Croatian state would be intolerable for Serbs, and it would justify their aggression against us.

    Like

    • I agree Tomislav Rapin, only I think that those who made the relevant in 2002 did little research on how other democratic countries fare with laws on bilingual signage and ethnic minorities so that it could be comparable to other countries. Hence, the new push to make Croatian law similar to other EU countries laws. But also, those who profess the movement against Cyrillic in Vukovar is discrimination etc forget, on purpose I think, that the same law also says the measure of bilingual signage should only be put into practice to promote peace, understanding and tolerance etc etc – so this is not the case in Vukovar for it seems peace etc can only be achieved if the victims of aggression and war crimes receive justice via prosecution of all suspected and known criminals and revealing where the missing bodies of those killed are etc… the issue is not simple, by far.

      Like

Trackbacks

  1. […] Vukovar, as the world already knows, is a city devastated to the ground through Serb aggression, ethnic cleansing of non-Serbs, mass murders and mass rapes during the war for Croatian independence in 1991. In November/December 2013 the group of Croatian citizens consisting mainly of war veterans “Committee for the defence of Croatian Vukovar” after a series of protests against bilingual signs on public buildings in Vukovar, which included the tearing down of these and consequent unrests and arrest as well as violent attacks against the protesters by members of the police, collected over 600,000 signatures for a referendum aiming to raise to 50% (compared with 33% under the current law), the minimum level for minority groups living in a city or a municipality to enjoy the right to bilingualism on public buildings, institutions. The “Committee for the defence of Croatian Vukovar” group and its many supporters want the city that suffered the most in the war (Vukovar) to be declared a place of special piety. […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Disclaimer, Terms and Conditions:

All content on “Croatia, the War, and the Future” blog is for informational purposes only. “Croatia, the War, and the Future” blog is not responsible for and expressly disclaims all liability for the interpretations and subsequent reactions of visitors or commenters either to this site or its associate Twitter account, @IVukic or its Facebook account. Comments on this website are the sole responsibility of their writers and the writer will take full responsibility, liability, and blame for any libel or litigation that results from something written in or as a direct result of something written in a comment. The nature of information provided on this website may be transitional and, therefore, accuracy, completeness, veracity, honesty, exactitude, factuality and politeness of comments are not guaranteed. This blog may contain hypertext links to other websites or webpages. “Croatia, the War, and the Future” does not control or guarantee the accuracy, relevance, timeliness or completeness of information on any other website or webpage. We do not endorse or accept any responsibility for any views expressed or products or services offered on outside sites, or the organisations sponsoring those sites, or the safety of linking to those sites. Comment Policy: Everyone is welcome and encouraged to voice their opinion regardless of identity, politics, ideology, religion or agreement with the subject in posts or other commentators. Personal or other criticism is acceptable as long as it is justified by facts, arguments or discussions of key issues. Comments that include profanity, offensive language and insults will be moderated.
%d bloggers like this: