Croatia: Snappish Coalitions For Snap Elections

Croatian Elections 2016

Early general elections in Croatia coming up second weekend of September 2016 have not only got behind them the brutally rushed toppling of a short-lived minority HDZ/Croatian Democratic Union–led government amidst founded and unfounded scandals, but are seeing the formation of snappish coalitions and an emergence of miniature political parties and individuals with irritating and irritable chips on their shoulders. All this spells out a possibility that the election results could well come back and bite the Croatian citizens in the back. With some unnatural coalitions between political parties that primarily point to individual candidate desperation to win seats at all costs and the stepping up the rhetoric on the stale dog’s breakfast of a guaranteed fantastic and prosperous future where there’ll be jobs for all, no thieves or corrupt in the public administration and public companies, debilitating foreign debt beat to a pulp and such, one really has difficulties is seeing much change on the political leadership scene from the previous elections of last decade or so. The only change that perhaps one might see is in seemingly more aggressive competition to secure local votes for individuals or smaller parties acting locally rather than nationally. It appears that most of the political coalitions in the elections race are counting on the draining of individual votes from bigger rival political parties to individual candidates running against those rival parties and who perhaps have local prestige or respect regardless of the fact they and their programs are hopeless for the nation as a whole. HDZ and its partners continue to emit the most sober campaign in comparison to the other parties.

 

For the parliament of 151 seats there are, according to the Croatian Electoral Commission) 2, 456 candidates (40% women; age range between 18 and 90 years) registered and are vying for a seat, including 29 candidates for ethnic minorities. 2016 polls will dish out to the voters 20 various coalitions of 60 political parties, 29 political parties going independently, 3 lists of independent candidates and 6 lists of candidates for ethnic minorities. The sheer numbers of candidates is enough to give any person desirous of a stable government and stable political climate a migraine. It’s very clear that these elections are much about securing a seat for an individual candidate and then pinning it to the victory of their coalition’s leading party. Croatia is bound to be the big loser if the coalitions formed to muster up individual local candidate wins into a win of government or significant number of seats actually win government. The disarray will no longer be in the uncompromising differences between political parties’ platforms but within the actual coalition trying to govern the country as if it’s one party.

In this turbulent sea of thousands of candidates and dozens of political parties running for government the Croatian media has so far given the impression that there are, after all, some leading political camps that have good chances of winning either majority or minority government or the chance to contribute to the forming of a future government.

Andrej Plenkovic, HDZ/Croatian Democratic Union Photo: Screenshot hrt.hr 3 September 2016

Andrej Plenkovic,
HDZ/Croatian Democratic Union
Photo: Screenshot hrt.hr 3 September 2016

The centre-right party Croatian Democratic Union, HDZ, was the relative winner in November 2015 elections when it won 59 seats. With Tihomir Oreskovic as its technocratic Prime Minister HDZ held minority government with Most/Bridge group of independents only to be toppled amidst scandals in June of this year. HDZ was at the helm of Croatia leading it into secession from communist Yugoslavia and holding government between 1990 and 2000, during the war years, as well as between 2003 and 2011. The new HDZ leader Andrej Plenkovic, a experienced diplomat and EU parliamentarian, was elected as party president in July of this year, seemingly turning the party more to the centre. HDZ decided to compete in the elections alone this time, only considering coalition with individual candidates/partners from smaller parties in certain local areas. Its election campaign trail appears to be spotted with significant victory projections across traditionally conservative electorates but not seemingly enough to project at this stage an outright majority government win on September 11. One thing that’s standing out in HDZ election campaign is its rather successful thrust to present Plenkovic to the Croatian public as a desirable leader for the country, however, the campaign appears in my view to lack adequate presentation of the other ingredient usually associated with election victory: presentation of a strong team rather than individual that will lead Croatia into a better future.

Bozo Petrov Most/Bridge of independent parties Photo: Screenshot hrt.hr 3 September 2016

Bozo Petrov
Most/Bridge of independent lists
Photo: Screenshot hrt.hr 3 September 2016

The Most/Bridge of Independent Lists is a relatively new political party functioning as a group of individual politicians, small-town and municipal mayors formed in 2012 in the small town of Metkovic that claimed and claims to be a ‘third way’ party – the solution to get Croatia out of the rut of a two-party system or two big political parties dominating the political scene in Croatia. It secured 19 seats in November 2015 elections and, hence, became the element that shook and rattled Croatia for a few weeks to finally decide to side with HDZ rather than centre-left Social Democrats/SDP in forming Croatia’s short-lived government in January 2016. It’s president Bozo Petrov, a 37-year-old psychiatrist from Metkovic, where he has been mayor since 2013 has lost a number of his coalition members due to disputes but regardless of that Most/Bridge is still expected to come in as a “third force” and perhaps once again be the one to call the shots which of the major parties (HDZ or SDP) will form the future government even if Petrov says that Most will never go into a coalition again.

History repeats itself saying has never to my knowledge come with good or a positive thing.

 

Zoran Milanovic SDP/Social DEmocratic Party Photo: Screenshot hrt.hr 3 September 2016

Zoran Milanovic
SDP/Social Democratic Party
Photo: Screenshot hrt.hr 3 September 2016

In its new coalition the centre-left SDP/Social Democratic Party (the former League of Communists) led by Zoran Milanovic has changed its name from Croatia Grows to the People’s Coalition and added or changed the parties in its coalition to the point that spells out desperation to win even if judging by its performance in the 2011-2015 government – it should be placed on a political scrap heap for quite a number of years. This time around SDP continues to work with the centre-left Croatian People’s Party/HNS and has pulled in new coalition partners in the Croatian Party of Pensioners, HSU, and the centre-right Croatian Peasants’ Party, HSS, which was a part of the HDZ-led Patriotic Coalition last November. It seems that HSS’s leader’s Kreso Beljak’s history of vandalism and theft convictions under the crimes law makes no difference in SDP’s selection of its coalition partner’s. While the notions of rehabilitation and second chances may be an acceptable way to lead life they certainly don’t factor as acceptable for members of a government in my book, especially when there’s much noise about corruption and theft in government bodies. Social Democrats are leading a campaign of dirt slinging against HDZ especially, and yet they themselves seem to have gathered quite a bit of dirt under their wings, showing it off, even, without blinking an eye. Not a good look for a party desirous of winning government but – there it is.

Ivan Lovrinovic (L) and Ivan Vilibor Sincic (R) Only Option Coalition Photo: makarsko-primorje.com

Ivan Lovrinovic (L) and
Ivan Vilibor Sincic (R)
Only Option Coalition
Photo: makarsko-primorje.com

The so-called Only Option Coalition was formed in July and is led by the anti-establishment Living Wall. Living Wall was created in 2011 from a civic movement fighting foreclosures and evictions by occupying buildings and is led by Ivan Vilibor Sincic. Three former Most/Bridge MPs, as well as the Association Franak (an NGO set up to lobby for people with loans in Swiss francs, whose debts rose due to a steep rise in the value of the franc) join living Wall in the coalition. The Only Option Coalition is said to be gaining momentum that may, as far as seats won is concerned,  place it on equal footing to the Most/Bridge wins and, therefore, make it an another camp with which a future minority government would negotiate terms to form government especially since Most/Bridge says it will not enter into any coalition with anybody.

Milan Bandic Coalition for Prime Minister Photo: hrt.hr

Milan Bandic
Coalition for Prime Minister
Photo: hrt.hr

The veteran Zagreb Mayor Milan Bandic and his party Bandic Milan 365 – Party of Labour and Solidarity, leads the current Coalition for Prime Minister. Bandic, an ex-SDP member, has joined forces with two other ex-major party members who are factoring noticeably on the Croatian political scene: Ivo Baldasar from city of Split, an ex-SDP and Radimir Cacic of Reformists, an ex- HNS member. Bandic’s coalition also claims to be Croatia’s answer for a “third way”, however current polls predictions are quite slim for this camp – up to 2 or 3 seats in total.
There are two regional parties that won seats at the November elections and are likely to win some at the upcoming polls: the Istrian Democratic Assembly, IDS, and the Croatian Democratic Alliance of Slavonia and Baranja, HDSSB. While IDS is likely to continue favouring SDP as they themselves are riddled with former communists, HDSSB if it wins seats although ideologically close to the more right than centre-right is likely to keep its final preferences in the pocket to the last minute.

Archbishop Zelimir Puljic

Archbishop Zelimir Puljic

While polls suggest that a week before elections every fifth voter is undecided (HRT news 3 September 2016) and, therefore, surprises are possible including a majority government elected, the fact remains that neither of the two major parties seem to have done much work in wooing new voters into their camps and the election results will demonstrate that a large number of Croatian voters leaning towards the centre-left parties have made little if any progress in leaving the lingering pro-communist Yugoslavia mentality behind. Perhaps that is why the Croatian Bishops have Thursday 25 August sent via Archbishop of Zadar Zelimir Puljic their own message to Croatian voters to “familiarise themselves with candidates’ programs, especially the ones to do with the economy and to focus their attention on how individual political parties intend to continue with the process of education reform and the democratisation of the society as well as the confrontation with the communist past.” Could not have said it better myself. Ina Vukic, Prof. (Zgb); B.A., M.A.Ps. (Syd)

Comments

  1. Whilst I firmly believe in the separation of Church and State and think all too often the Church has it’s own agenda when it starts interfering in the election process, I can’t help but agree with the message sent out by Archbishop Pujic to the people of Croatia this time.
    He still allows people to make up their own minds and form opinions based on political rhetoric but he is gently guiding them towards voting for progress rather than a retrograde step back towards Communism. I hope the people take heed.
    Personally, I found the toppling of the previous Government left a bad taste in the mouth and it was undemocratic in the extreme. But, we are still dealing with a relatively new Country riddled with fears from the past at the hands of the Communists who under various guises would still like to take the people back to the bad old days.These are people adept at lies, at spreading dissension and not above making threats to get their way.
    Therefore I urge the Croatian people to heed the words of one who seems to care about the direction Croatia is taking and ignore any religious element, but concentrate on the message that Croatia must move forward to the future and create a truly democratic state that can lead the way for other ex communist countries to escape their past.
    It will be a shame if the fracturing of so many parties by the new coalitions leads to no overall majority with the right to form a Government. I’d like to see HDZ win outright to try and give a settled period to Croatian politics bu at this point it seems unlikely.
    I wish the people of Croatia a settled future free of the fear that has accompanied Governments of the past. I wish them progress and the right to take their place in a Europe of their choosing.
    xxx Massive Hugs xxx

    Like

    • The election campaigns have become so filled with garbage, David, that it’s getting hard for an ordinary swinging voter or the undecided one to start making decisions, hence the church’s words are well placed. They also remind the voter that each and every one is important and that Croatia still has a long way to go in shedding communist barriers from the past. I agree with you re separation of Church from State and this time around the church did well to try and help voters make up their own mind. Hugs, hugs, hugs XXX

      Liked by 1 person

  2. 30% of Croatian people are still at heart communists, 30 % naive, 30 % real conservatives that love Croatia unconditionally, 10% swing like Tarzan in the jungle and no wonder that SDP ( Serbian party not social democrats ) wins plenty of votes. Must change that quick smart before the red get redder

    Like

  3. It seems to me Ina.. as I view the world of politics from my own narrow perspective of understanding.. That where ever I look around the world stage, politics seem to be coming undone at the seams..
    Maybe the world is undergoing major changes in this area, and yet while we in our different countries have various upheavals and power battles, it seems as I detach and look on, Change is happening all over as those in power fall pray to scandles and coruption… Without the voter they would not be in power..

    People are now ( speaking from the UK ) are no longer voting via parties their parents voted for.. They are actually now Listening intently to what is being said. And using their votes to be heard and engage change..

    Change and reform is needed as people wake up to those who control..
    I know even less about Croatia’s politics.. But can see via reading and learning from your posts Ina that people are Waking Up!

    Love and Blessings to you..
    hugs Sue xxx

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes I find the same with Australian youth, Sue, listening closely and making weighed decisions who to vote for and that is good. Croatia has lots of great young people who are educated and “street-wise” as far as world democracy is concerned and I hope they hurry up and bring changes…

      Liked by 1 person

      • I am sure they will, The youth of today are very ‘street-wise’ and I am sure each will vote with their hearts.. ❤

        Like

      • Cheers, Sue – we wait and see however I reckon a handful of elections still to come before the results show the youth’s prudence…but that too is good, much better than no hope, I like the fact that Croatia’s youth wants a good life and are willing to gain skills and practice professionalism in work…they need more opportunities and that too will come

        Liked by 2 people

      • It will.. its taken its time here too.. at one time we had many skills here in the UK.. Now with industries going overseas the skill base is in decline.. Thankfully we are seeing a new programme for Apprenticeships being launched.. The young are seeing they can learn a skill and work there way through to the top.. And not start with huge debts from University Grants.. Where when they leave they are often in catch 22.. As employers request work experience.. It seems we are going around in a circular cycle .. Education is put high on the agenda and rightly so.. But we forget what keeps a country tick-tocking!… And that is skills in jobs…

        Like

      • Right on, Sue – nothing without skills in jobs 🙂 Hugs

        Liked by 1 person

      • 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  4. This is simply depressing. No progress made in Cro. People get what they deserve. I still don’t understand how it is that the left are even considered by voters – communist legacy, anti-Cro independence, terrible economic managers, murderous state apparatus, standard bearer of lies and deception, destroyed cro sovereignty, made us the laughing stock of the world, allowed Greater Serbia resurgence etc. I am sorry, but Croatians are capable of governing themselves effectively.

    Like

  5. What complicated politics, but maybe it always appears that way to outsiders. I wish the best for Croatia.

    Like

    • Yes complicated, Luanne, navigating through it all for information to choose best candidate of oneself is tricky and I think it’s similar in many other countries where MPs have forgotten that they represent people…:)

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Zeljko Glasnovic or Zlatko Hasanbegovic for premier!
    I only trust them, Steve Culej and Bruna Esih!
    You can’t have a healthy and functioning government, judiciary, school system, economy, media, SOCIETY….if those in power are the descendants of Croatia-hating commis or are directly responsible for crimes committed from 1945 to 1990 and during the recent homeland war. You cannot have people in power who have a pathological hatred for a country and its residents, yet live like parasites off of government grants, kickbacks, etc..

    Like

    • It’s what communism taught people. Veronika – to be parasites or expect the “state”to provide them with a living. There were exceptions to that, people who lived through hard work – but on the whole wages guaranteed regardless of productivity… it pains to even imagine hard core reds may get a chance at gov again…

      Like

  7. Oh my gosh! What a mess. How can this result in anything productive going anywhere, doing anything?

    Like

  8. Something to watch BEFORE the upcoming election this weekend. Croatians seem to have very short collective memories. Do we want the same communists pictured elected into power?

    Like

    • Collective conscience needs a reminder, indeed, Veronika – thank you for the link, a very hard and difficult pain to watch but it must be so people don’t forget and remember even more at election times for democratic progress

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Disclaimer, Terms and Conditions:

All content on “Croatia, the War, and the Future” blog is for informational purposes only. “Croatia, the War, and the Future” blog is not responsible for and expressly disclaims all liability for the interpretations and subsequent reactions of visitors or commenters either to this site or its associate Twitter account, @IVukic or its Facebook account. Comments on this website are the sole responsibility of their writers and the writer will take full responsibility, liability, and blame for any libel or litigation that results from something written in or as a direct result of something written in a comment. The nature of information provided on this website may be transitional and, therefore, accuracy, completeness, veracity, honesty, exactitude, factuality and politeness of comments are not guaranteed. This blog may contain hypertext links to other websites or webpages. “Croatia, the War, and the Future” does not control or guarantee the accuracy, relevance, timeliness or completeness of information on any other website or webpage. We do not endorse or accept any responsibility for any views expressed or products or services offered on outside sites, or the organisations sponsoring those sites, or the safety of linking to those sites. Comment Policy: Everyone is welcome and encouraged to voice their opinion regardless of identity, politics, ideology, religion or agreement with the subject in posts or other commentators. Personal or other criticism is acceptable as long as it is justified by facts, arguments or discussions of key issues. Comments that include profanity, offensive language and insults will be moderated.
%d bloggers like this: